When Jesse Solomon Claims West Was in Love With Amanda

Jesse Solomon is spilling the tea — and bringing his timeline receipts — and revealing when West Wilson allegedly first said he loved Amanda Batula.

After teasing on three-part Summer House reunion that he had a “timeline” of when West, 31, and Amanda’s romance, Jesse, 33, finally dropped his account of events via Instagram on Wednesday, June 10.

One of the most eye-opening allegations revolved around the moment West allegedly revealed he was falling hard for Amanda, 34, the day they confirmed their romance in a March 31 joint statement — after they both previously denied they were seeing each other.

“March 31: The news drops. Confirms everything. I call West out for lying — he’s nonchalant,” Jesse claimed in his breakdown. “I ask how long it’s been. ‘A little over a month,’ he says. He tells me he thinks he loves her.”

As fans of Summer House may remember, West and Amanda played coy about how serious their relationship is during the season 10 reunion, filmed in April.

In fact, West told his costars during part 3 of the reunion that he and Amanda were “not using the word ‘love’ right now.”

“It’s been two months, three months,” West said during the Tuesday, June 9, episode, to which Amanda added, “It’s so early.”

Amanda told the group, including her estranged husband Kyle Cooke, that although she and West “haven’t said” that they “love” each other, they were “having conversations about [how] serious our feelings [are] and where it’s going.” (Amanda and Kyle, 43, announced their split in January after four years of marriage.)

During the third installment of the reunion, Kyle asked the pair whether they’d hooked up in 2025 after rumors swirled about that time frame.

“No. F*** no,” West claimed.

West, who previously dated Summer House’s Ciara Miller — Amanda’s one-time BFF — in 2023, also denied he was seeing Amanda during Super Bowl weekend, which took place on February 8.

Jesse, however, poked holes in West and Amanda’s timeline with his own records. (The couple previously claimed they first kissed at the end of February and didn’t sleep together until after they released their March 31 statement.)

Jesse’s timeline began on February 10, two days after West and Kyle were together in Seattle for the Super Bowl.

According to Jesse, West and Amanda went to dinner in Miami “without me” on February 10.

The date tracks with Kyle’s reunion claim that he was texting West that day about his and Amanda’s “sex life or lack thereof” without any idea Amanda was at the dinner with him.

“Feb 27: A friend of a friend says W& A ‘seemed into each other’ and left a bar together,” Jesse claimed on Wednesday, noting that “same week” Brianna “Chickenfry” LaPaglia was “telling people they’re hooking up.” (Brianna, 26, claimed West told her at the Super Bowl he and Amanda were a “thing.”)

One day later, Jesse and Kyle had “brunch with the boys,” and West left the meal to have “another brunch with A and friends.” Jesse claimed West didn’t “mention” Amanda would be at the lunch when he left.

“Later, Kyle and I run into them at a bar. W&A are sitting next to each other. A jumps up when she sees us, kisses Kyle on the mouth,” Jesse alleged of the February 28 run-in. “I joke, ‘I can’t believe you and West are dating.’ She says, “West’s my boiii.’ Kyle and I leave. W, A and friends apparently head back to W’s place.”

On March 2, Jesse recalled telling costar Lindsay Hubbard about his “suspicions,” but she reportedly said “no way” was he right.

“March 3: Tell W that Kyle was annoyed he ditched brunch for A. W says: ‘It’s not weird, we hang out a lot as friends — always in groups,’” per Jesse.

Two days later, Jesse revealed he asked West about the rumors floating around and West allegedly told him, “‘We’re half as bad as you and Ciara, like, the PG version,’” referring to Jesse flirting with Ciara, 30, all the time.

On March 6, Jesse said he FaceTimed Ciara and she was allegedly “suspicious too.” Kyle, however, still thought “nothing is going on” when Jesse called him the same day.

Jesse claimed that Kyle did, however, tell him at the time that “A’s location was off the morning after we ran into them at the bar.”

By March 10, Jesse said he started to receive heat from West after a Reddit thread claimed Jesse was saying, “I think they’re f***ing.”

He claimed that West asked him to “stop feeding into it,” to which Jesse allegedly responded, “I say I’m not telling randos in Cabo that I think you’re hooking up.”

The following day, Jesse recalled having drinks with Amanda where he said she was in “full denial” mode, and didn’t confirm any of his suspicions.

When March 20 rolled around, Jesse said he attended a Neutrogena event in Miami with Ciara and Lindsay, 39, and revealed that “everyone’s suspicious” now.

Jesse “randomly” went out with West on March 21, and Amanda was there too, which he said he “didn’t know” beforehand.

“We all go back to his place. A jokes, sarcastically, ‘Are you gonna add this to the list of reasons why you think I’m f***ing my best friend?’ I leave,” Jesse alleged.

The next day, Jesse claimed that Kyle checked his “Find My Friends” app and Amanda allegedly “stayed over” at West’s place.

“March 30: Rumors spreading, but I still believe them that ‘nothing’s true’ based on what they’ve told me. I text W love and support feeling bad for them,” Jesse added, before noting that one day later Amanda and West came clean publicly.